Monday 18 September 2017

The Orville Review: “Command Performance”

Kermit take the wheel
(This review contains spoilers!)

          I saw enough promise in The Orville that I felt it was deserving enough of a second chance that it’d be worth coming back at least one more time to see if the crew can build on the flimsy foundation the pilot left behind. And while this episode is marginally better than the one that came before it, it still suffers from all the problems that plagued them last week.

          While on an away mission, Captain McFarlane and his wife have been poofed away to some unknown location, and the security officer has been left in charge of the ship because Spirit Halloween Worf is busy laying an egg.

          Thank you for not clicking off while reading that, by the way. I wish I could’ve clicked off watching this episode.

          Of course all sorts of sci-fi hijinks ensue, as we see the security officer grapple with how hard it is to be in control, as well as McFarlane and his wife trying to escape their new home of an alien zoo.

          The show’s biggest problem continues to blare loud and clear. It’s rarely funny, especially when it tries to be. The two good jokes in the episode are the very first one and the very last one. Everything in between is either groan-worthy or facepalm-worthy. There’s a reason why Star Trek never used pop-culture references, and it’s because they just don’t fit in a show set hundreds of years in the future. Granted, this episode does find ways to make them endearing, like the Kermit doll on McFarlane’s desk and the hilarious solution to the zoo problem at the end, but a random Dora the Explorer namedrop comes right out of nowhere and feels completely out of place in this setting.

          The writing hasn’t improved either. The trio of leads are still just plain horrible people, and not the funny kind of horrible you see on Seinfeld. Their lines range from annoying to insufferable, and once McFarlane and his wife returned to the episode after a good chunk of time off-screen, I actually let out a “Noooooo!” I hate watching them that much.

          Thankfully, the security officer subplot is…better, but not by much. While I enjoyed her in the first episode, here we can see that her acting ability leaves quite a bit to be desired. When it comes to a show like this, there’s corny acting, and there’s “I don’t give a crap and I’m just reading the lines” acting. This was the latter. Maybe this was just an off day for her, but considering this was a big lead role she needs to do better.

          At the end of the day, this episode is better than the first one…slightly. It got a few more good jokes in than the first one, and the sci-fi stuff was done better than the first one. But the problems continue to rear their ugly heads, as the majority of the jokes are still annoying and the characters are all still unlikeable. And it really hurts, because I so desperately want to love this show. Every episode it gets so close, but then misses the mark completely.

          Oh well.

FINAL SCORE
4/10

Mediocre

No comments:

Post a Comment